Smokin' Ed's Pineapple Teriyaki (Mild) Hot Sauce Review

Smokin’ Ed’s Pineapple Teriyaki (Mild) 

Another addition to the Smokin’ Ed’s line and this time, we see another take on an Asian flavor style, namely that of teriyaki. I don’t know if there is a difference per se between Teriyaki and Pineapple Teriyaki, though the latter suggests more of a Japanese by way of Hawaii vibe, but this does not seem to be trying to be an actual teriyaki sauce, but more of perhaps a teriyaki-inspired hot sauce. Whereas most teriyaki sauces tend to be heavily soy sauce based and frequently much thicker and dense brown concoctions, this one is a pretty swift turning away from that aesthetic.

This is, instead, a rather lively and vibrant red, with perhaps some slight lean towards brown. The color matches the flavor profile here and the entire result strikes me more as playful, in a very good way. The first few times I had this, until I got enough room in the bottle to properly agitate, this came across as hyper-sweet, almost cloyingly so. I did not find that enjoyable, though my immediate thought was that this was much more towards a sweet ‘n’ sour sauce than teriyaki. 

Once it settled in, I was able to get a lot more of the balance, from the subtle soy sauce flavoring, which here is more of an accent, to the pineapple dancing around with what I believe are red Jalapenos, as is my understanding all of the Smokin’ Ed’s mild sauces use as their pod. I quite like overall where this is going, flavor-wise, but it definitely isn’t really a hot sauce. Heat is low enough that I didn’t find it registering most of the time. While teriyaki itself is good on meats generally, I don’t know that this would transition as well to red meats like steaks. Though the sweetness did taper down as I got further into it, there isn’t quite the umami hit that actual teriyaki sauce has to work with the red meats and the lightness and sweetness of the pineapple doesn’t strike me as a happy union there. 

It is excellent on chicken, of course, but also on Asian foods generally, such as ramen. In many ways, it reminds me almost as much of an Asian-style sweet hot, with perhaps an nod to teriyaki, than to the actual flavoring of teriyaki itself. It’s a pretty neat trick to pull off and while I don’t know what exactly what Ed was going for with this sauce, the end result is pretty wonderful. 

Bottom line: Think of this more as perhaps a sweet & sour sauce by way of teriyaki, just on the really high end of things, and you’ll about have it.

Breakdown:

            Heat level: 0
            Flavor: 8
            Flexibility: 6
            Enjoyment to dollar factor: 8

Overall: 6