Brick & Mortars In Utah Update

It's been a good, good long time, all the way since July 2017,  since I did one of these. I really meant to get to this sooner and in fact, for a while, I was kicking around the idea of doing this yearly (feel free to click through the timeline for some of the earlier episodes). We have seen a pretty dramatic influx of spiciness to foods in 2020 (some of these I’ve done videos for in the YouTube FOH series), with a good percentage of the local grocers (Harmons, Fresh Market, Smith’s, etc.), expanding their selections notably. They still are a pretty far cry from any of the places on this list more dedicated to that specific product line, but it is nice to see the industry getting out there.

In the age of COVID-19, with businesses related to food dropping off right and left, I was a bit worried for all of these places and checked in with all of them at least once in 2020. The list is alphabetic and I will say there is a reason to go to all of them that are along the I-15 corridor, as they all have different strengths, some of those not really related to hot sauces specifically. As usual, all of them are also reviewed on my Yelp page, though I have not updated them all specifically to 2020.

Burn Your Tongue - Quilted Bear - Newgate Mall, Ogden, UT

700+ sauces. I might not need to add anything else to this, actually. This selection is intense and covers every spectrum of hot sauce you might think of, including some mustards and syrups. If you combined ALL of the shelf offerings of everyone else on this list, you’d probably break the century mark, maybe all the way to 150, but not much more. All of them. Combined. Roger, in addition to being the ambassador to spiciness, particularly with his support of the chilehead community, is also an all-around good guy and if you happen to catch him there, you’ll be treated to a great conversation about peppers, the industry, and exactly which sauce you should be taking with you, and maybe even a discount.

Grove Market - Salt Lake City, UT

This is what it sounds like, a small market servicing a deli counter that makes some of the tastiest sandwiches known to man. Everything there is in service to that, from the fresh desserts to the substantial drink selection to the snacks and so on. There is one neck-high shelving unit that is dedicated to the sauces, but in that area is probably a good 50 or 60 different types, some of which I’ve seen nowhere else. Selection here is a pretty far cry from BYT, but still enough for 2nd.

Pepper Palace - Park City, UT

Hot on the heels of that, though, is Pepper Palace. This is dedicated to the Pepper Palace line, aside from some of the extraneous stuff they lifted from Pirate O’s, such as dried insects. This place has t-shirts and other novelty junk, some meat snacks, some BBQ sauces, some wing sauces, some salsas, a lot of dried stuff, rubs, etc, some pickled stuff. In fact, most of the floor and shelf space is dedicated to things other than hot sauces. For those sauces, which I did not pick up, as I was not in serious need and literally nothing enticed me, even after a good half hour of time spent checking out the wares, there is a lot of duplication, which suggested that there are, despite 40 - 50 labeled sauces, maybe half that number of actual sauces. It also suggests a base, which always strikes me as kind of a dangerous proposition. I have heard rumblings that they like to pick off other sauces, reverse engineer them and release as their own, but I cannot verify. I didn’t see a ton of things that struck me as exact copies, but more than a few things that seemed more intended as analogues to other sauces. For a variety of reasons, not the least of which is that I hate Park City (it is about the same distance from me as Pirate O’s and I’ve been to Pepper Palace exactly once ever), this is pretty low on my list of things to get to, though I did find enough stuff that I’m vaguely interested in that I might try some of it in 2021, if I ever managed to free up shelf space.

Pirate O's - Draper, UT

More of a Euro/quasi-Scandinavian import store than anything else, though they extend the range a bit more each time I come in. The owner seems somewhat of a chilehead, and is also another good guy that I’ve enjoyed chatting with about sauces, but a couple of shelving units along the back wall means he’s deferring to other stuff that probably sells better and is more profitable, though selection has been better this year than at other times in the past. Even still, this one has a single digit (probably a low single digit) percentage of the available retail space dedicated to hot sauces and spicy stuff overall, but there are some gems here that I also don’t seem to run across anywhere else. This is well worth keeping tabs on, but moreso for the FOH series rather than the blog these days. I’d put this one closer to a tie with Grove, just depending on my mood on a given day, but will also not that I have a soft spot for it, as it gamely tried to provide when BYT was on hiatus. I enjoy the visits here a lot, just something warm and comfortable about it, that so-called je ne sais quoi.

And...so...we conclude another breakdown. All of them along the I-15 corridor are definitely worth a visit, but as a finale to this, in my end ringing endorsement, I again note that I have ceased buying sauces online entirely, in favor of brick-and-mortars, and that is largely due to BYT, which remains my overall favorite.