
Note: Video support available here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kZMz2_8963Q
A note before I start the review proper, which I don't usually do. As you may have surmised from either my numerous Yelp reviews or this blog, I'm based in Salt Lake City. As such, I find it opportune to have a go-to grocer. That one for me (and one of the largest in the area) is Smith's, which is part of the Kroger family. The "Private Selection" label refers to their higher end house/store brand. They have recently launched a line called "Culinary Hot Sauce" within it.
I have chosen to start with the best of the lot for this introduction, the Mango Scotch Bonnet. As regular readers may have noted, my favorite pepper generally is the Cayenne. Say that someone asked for my second-favorite. Odds are, it would probably be the Scotch Bonnet, which is kind of odd, I suppose, considering my general disdain for its close relative, the Habanero. There, however, as the saying goes, it is, though. I have yet to have a bad hot sauce with Scotch Bonnet, providing they don't also include my two nemesises (nemesi?), that being extract and onions. I also find the Scotch Bonnet to be one of the tastier peppers in general.
I will say I have not had a solid Mango-hot sauce...until now, that is. Despite misgivings, considering this is a sauce from a large grocer containing what I consider a very volatile flavoring element, it succeeded wildly. It captures, somehow, the fruit well, with both that sort of tangy tartness frequently a hallmark of the fruit, with the distinct sweetness it is known for. It also rounds it out nicely with that flavor profile and (admittedly minor) heat that the Scotch Bonnet provides. This is a well-crafted and well-blended sauce and my main (and perhaps only) complaint is the idiot cap that comes with it, something that plagues the entire line. A dropper cap with a glass bottle with a thick sauce is a shit combination and they should not have made that choice, as one has to remove the cap entirely for usage to make any sense at all.
Bottom line: This is the best of the lot for the Culinary Hot Sauce line from Private Selection. Only minor heat and is best used as a dipping sauce, but the flavor profile is excellent. Worth a look.
Breakdown:
Heat level: 3
Flavor: 8
Flexibility: 6
Enjoyment to dollar factor: 8
Overall: 6





